Get Permission Kahlon and Agnihotri: Variations in mandibular coronoid process-A morphometric treatise


Introduction

Coronoid process in Greek means “like a crown”. In lower animals, separate coronoid bones are present which articulate with the splenial, angular and supra angular bones to form a common “dentary bone” which is homologous to mandible in humans.1

The coronoid process of mandible is of clinical significance for maxillofacial surgeons for reconstructive purposes as it is used as graft for reconstruction of osseous defects in oral and facio-maxillary region.2 Anatomical variations in the coronoid process can result in extremely narrow vestibular space due the close proximity of the medial aspect of the coronoid process to the distal molar.3

The present morphometric treatise focuses on variant anatomy of the coronoid process in Indian population.The study provides baseline data for Indian population which has clinical implications and repercussions.

Materials and Methods

The material for the present study comprised of 500 adult human mandibles. These mandibles were obtained from the different medical colleges in the state of Punjab. Any mandible broken or dysmorphic were excluded from the study.

The coronoid height was measured as distance between the coronoid and most protruding portion of inferior border of the ramus of mandible (Figure 1).

The length of coronoid process was taken from the line tangential to the deepest part of mandibular notch to apex of the coronoid process (Figure 2).

Results

The shape of coronoid process was classified into 3 types: (Figure 3)

  1. Triangular: Tip pointing directly upwards.

  2. Rounded: Tip rounded.

  3. Hook: Tip pointing backwards.

Three incidence percentage for round, triangular and hook shaped coronoid processes came out to be 46, 42 and 12 respectively. The mean value of height and length of coronoid process was determined to be 60.62 mm and 12.53 mm respectively. (Table 1, Table 2 )

Discussion

The coronoid process develops as a discrete entity within the mass of the temporalis muscle anlage, subsequently it unites with the main portion of mandibular ramus at approximately eight weeks of age.4 The largest portion of temporalis muscle is attached to the apex, whole of the medial surface and anterior part of lateral surface of coronoid process. The remaining part of lateral surface provides attachment to anterior fibres of masseter. These two are important muscles of mastication which show morpho functional dependence.

Several authors have described the various shapes of coronoid process. According to which, some processes are triangular, hook shaped and rounded 5, 6, 7 whereas others have described it as beak shaped.8 The shape and size of coronoid process is influenced by dietary habit, genetic constitution, hormonal and mainly by temporalis muscle activity.9 In the present study, the incidence of the rounded shape was the highest followed by the triangular shape. In most studies in India the triangular shape was most commonly observed. In previous studies in Turkish population10 and Bangladeshi population11 the most common shape observed was the hook shape. (Table 3, Table 4)

The coronoid process projects upwards and slightly forwards. It has a top border and is convex in shape, while its lower part is concave in shape. Its margins and medial surface provide attachment to temporalis muscle. The coronoid process is suitable for paranasal augmentation. Its clinical application is also favourable because its size and morphology fits into the paranasal region, with the additional advantages of biocompatibility, availability, and reduced operation time for harvesting.12, 13 The present study focuses on the height and length of coronoid process of mandible with the aim to characterize the morphological profile of the coronoid process in Indian population. This will benefit dental surgery, anthropological and forensic practice.

Coronoid process enlargement may be seen in some pathological conditions like osteochondroma, exostosis, osteoma and other developmental anomalies. Though fracture of mandible is common, but incidence of coronoid fracture is rare (2%) and requires no treatment unless impingement on the zygomatic arch is present. Coronoid process hyperplasia is a very rare cause of mandibular hypomobility. So, it is usually underdiagnosed, but a thorough background anatomical knowledge can help in examining the patient clinically and radiologically.14, 15 This ultimately will help in the line of management and a better clinical outcome.16

The coronoid process can be removed intra-orally without any functional deficiency and facial disfigurement. It is expected that a knowledge of the morphometric profile of the coronoid process in different populations will aid the clinician in reconstruction procedures such as those pertaining to orbit floor, alveolar defects, paranasal sinus augumentation, non union fracture mandible, osseous defects reconstruction and other repair procedures in cranio-maxillo facial surgeries.17, 18

Figure 1

Showing measurement procedure for coronoid height

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/9e6b7ea0-23ea-4001-a835-d4575bb03c06image1.png
Figure 2

AB is length of coronoid process

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/9e6b7ea0-23ea-4001-a835-d4575bb03c06image2.png
Figure 3

Showing the triangular, hook shaped and rounded coronoid processes (left to right)

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/9e6b7ea0-23ea-4001-a835-d4575bb03c06image3.png
Table 1

Showing variations of shape of coronoid process in mandible

Shape

Number of mandibles

Percentage incidence

Triangular

210

42%

Hook Shaped

060

12%

Rounded

230

46%

Table 2

Showing metric parameters related to coronoid process of mandible

Parameters

Mean value

Standard deviation

Height

60.62

5.95

Length

12.53

2.75

Table 3

Comparison of shape of coronoid process in different populations

Authors (Year)

Population

Triangular

Hook shaped

Rounded

Khan TA and Sharieff JH 5 (2011)

South India

67%

30%

3%

Prajapati VP et al 6(2011)

Western Indians

54.17%

21.25%

24.58%

Desai VC et al 7(2014)

South-west Indians

136 (68%)

48 (24%)

16 (8%)

Pradhan S et al 1 (2014)

Eastern Indians

86 (46.73%)

33 (17.93%)

65 (35.3%)

Present study (2020)

Indians

210 (42%)

60 (12%)

230 (46%)

Table 4

Showing comparison of coronoid height of mandible in different populations

Authors (Year)

Population

Mean ± SD

Koyama M 12 (1965)

Japanese

98.27±5.2 (male) 91.85±5.6 (female)

Kumar MP and Lokanadham S 13 (2013)

South-east Indians

59.37±5.03

Sandeepa NC et al 14 (2017)

Saudi

74.18±5.78 (male) 63.28±5.06 (female)

Present study (2020)

Indians

60.62±5.95

Conclusions

Our study of coronoid process suggest that round shape is the most common presentation(46%) followed by triangular(42%) and then hook shaped(12%). This morphometric treatise provides valuable inputs relevant for anthropological comparisons, forensic investigations and reconstructive procedures.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

S S Pradhan D Bara S Patra S Nayak C Mohapatra Anatomical Study of Various Shapes of Mandibular Coronoid Process in Relation to Gender & AgeIOSR J Dent Med Sci20141380914

2 

P H Choung S G Kim The coronoid process for paranasal augmentation in the correction of midfacial concavityOral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod20019112833

3 

S M Mintz A Ettinger T Schmakel M J Gleason Contralateral coronoid process bone grafts for orbital floor reconstruction: An anatomic and clinical studyJ Oral Maxillofac Surg1998561011404

4 

M N Spyropoulos The morphogenetic relationship of the temporal muscle to the coronoid process in human embryos and fetusesAm J Anat19771503395409

5 

T A Khan J H Sharieff Observation on morphological features of human mandibles in 200 South Indian subjectsAnatomical Karnataka2011514453

6 

V P Prajapati O Malukar S K Nagar Variations in the morphological appearance of the coronoid process of human mandibleNational J Med Res2011126470

7 

V C Desai S D Desai H S Shaik Morphological study of mandibleJ Pharm Sci Res20146417577

8 

E A Schafer G D Thane Quain’s Elements of Anatomy: The bones of the head10th editionLongmans, Green & CoLondon189060

9 

H Kausar A Tripathi S Raizaday S Bharti S Jain S Khare Morphology and Morphometry of Coronoid Process of Dry Mandible- A Comprehensive StudyJournal of Evidence Based Medicine and Healthcare20207157736

10 

S Bakirci Ilknur Ari I M Kafa Morphometric characteristics and typology of coronoid process of the mandibleActa Med Mediterr20132946836

11 

A Hossain S M M Hossain S M Banna Famh Variations in the shape of the coronoid process in the adult human mandibleBangladesh J Anat2011927583

12 

M KOYAMA An Anthropological Study on the Mandible in the Japanese, especially Measurements in Relation to the Construction of an ArticulatorJ Nihon Univ Sch Dent1965715159

13 

M P Kumar S Lokanadham Sex determination & morphometric parameters of human mandibleInt J Res Med Sci201312936

14 

N C Sandeepa A A Ganem W A Alqhtani Y M Mousa E K Abdullah A H Alkhayri Mandibular indices for gender prediction: A retrospective radiographic study in Saudi populationJ Dent Oral Health20173917

15 

S Nayak S Patra G Singh C Mohapatra S Rath Study of the size of the coronoid process of mandibleJ Anatomical Soc India2016656S23

16 

S Nayak S Pradhan D P Bara S Patra Bilateral elongated coronoid process: A case reportIOSR J Dent Med Sci2015145614

17 

S Amrani G E Anastassov A H Montazem Mandibular Ramus/Coronoid Process Grafts in Maxillofacial Reconstructive SurgeryJ Oral Maxillofac Surg20106836416

18 

L Clauser C Curioni S Spanio The use of the temporalis muscle flap in facial and craniofacial reconstructive surgery. A review of 182 casesJ Craniomaxillofac Surg199523420314



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/10.18231/j.jds.2020.003


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 1002

PDF Downloaded: 840