- Visibility 142 Views
- Downloads 10 Downloads
- DOI 10.18231/j.jds.2023.010
-
CrossMark
Comparative evaluation of glycolic acid and salicylic acid peels followed by PRP for treatment of hyperpigmentation-A split face study
- Author Details:
-
Lavisha Arora
-
Karan Tyagi
-
Anjali Singh *
-
Joohi Chandra
-
Sumit Malhotra
-
Anshi Jain
-
Vidhya Sekhar
Lavisha Arora
Karan Tyagi
Introduction
Skin hyperpigmentation is a common dermatological condition in which the skin color generally becomes darker. Various internal and external factors including hormonal changes, inflammation, injury, acne, eczema, certain medication, UV exposure, etc influence skin color. (Perez-Bernal et al., 2000).[1] Melanin is a skin pigment produced by melanocytes in various layers of skin,affecting skin pigmentation and coloration. Thus, skin hyperpigmentation disorder is result of alterations in melanocyte production or distribution of melanin (Rossi & Perez, 2011). [2] Various commonly observed hyperpigmentation disorders include melasma, post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, ephelides, lentigines, and many more. Skin condition in which irregular patches of light to dark brown or gray–brown lesions appear on the sun exposed parts of the skin indicating to acquired hypermelanosis of skin, a condition which refers to Melasma (Katsambas & Antoniou, 1995; [3] Victor et al., 2004). It usually affects the face and the neck regions and predominantly observed in women (Handel et al., 2014). [4]
Hyperpigmentation is not considered a harmful or lethal disorder; however, it affects patients emotional and psychological health and it does exert influence on quality of life. Various treatment options are available for hyperpigmentation. These agents are primarily applied by topical route in the form of creams, gels, or ointments. These topical treatments can have some side effects such as skin drying, irritation, peeling, or hypopigmentation. Poor patient compliance and satisfaction can be observed in prolonged durations of treatment ranging for several months. The challenge of effective therapy to treat hyperpigmentation remains unresolved that lays emphasis on the need for novel treatment options.
Salicylic acid, a beta-hydroxy acid though traditionally used for acne, has also been tried in pigmentary disorders like melasma. Dark-skinned individuals including acne, melasma and postinflammatory hyperpigmentation, ethanol solutions of salicylic acid are excellent peeling agents in these conditions. The mechanism of action of salicylic acid is slightly different from that of glycolic acid peels in decreasing pigmentation. Salicylic acid is anti-inflammatory and thus it also serves to decrease the postinflammatory hyperpigmentation which usually follows the use of peeling agents on the skin. In addition, it has a diffuse whitening effect on the skin as shown in a study by Ahn and Kim. [5] In a pilot study by Grimes et al. [6] on dark-skinned individuals, 20-30% salicylic acid peel was used to treat acne, postinflammatory hyperpigmentation and melasma, and it was observed that almost two-thirds of the patients with melasma showed a moderate improvement. Only mild side effects were noted in 16% patients which were transient and resolved in one to two weeks. However, as there are no comparative studies, it is difficult to comment if the agent is better or inferior to the traditional glycolic peels.
Glycolic acid peel has the smallest molecular weight amongst all the alpha-hydroxy acids. It penetrates skin easily, making it a popular peel agent.[7] Glycolic acid has two carbon atoms: one carbon atom is with a carboxyl group and the other carbon atom is with a hydroxyl group. Glycolic acid is extremely hydrophilic. The pH of a non-buffered solution ranges from 0.08–2.75. [8] Previous authors have recommended the use of a buffered or partially neutralized glycolic acid, which is safer than free Glycolic acid. [9] Glycolic acid peels are commercially available as free acids, partially neutralized (higher pH), buffered, or esterified solutions. [10] They are available in various concentrations ranging from 20%–70%. The higher the concentration and lower the pH, the more intense the peeling will be. [11] In general, gel formulations have a slower penetration time and are easier to control. [12], [13]
Our study thus focuses on the therapeutic targets as well the various , novel and emerging therapies being approached for the better, effective, and timely management of hyperpigmentation by using the most potent chemical agents glycolic & salicylic acid were used followed by PRP therapy for pigmentation.
Materials and Methods
Study design and settings
The study was conducted at the Department of Periodontology and Oral Implantology, I.T.S. Center for Dental Studies and Research, Muradnagar, Ghaziabad from May 2021 to October 2021.
Sample size
A total of 200 patients of both the sex with acne scars, hyperpigmentation were included for the above study. The study was split face comparative observational study.
Inclusion criteria
Patients of both sex with acne scars or hyperpigmentation.
Age between 20 to 60 years.
Patients with lesions limited to face only.
Patients with hyperpigmented areas on their face only.
Exclusion criteria
Patients taking any acne-inducing drugs.
Patients with hormonal acne (patient with known h/o PCOD, menstrual irregularities and patient on hormonal therapy for acne.
Patients with active/recurrent herpes infection.
Patients with a history of hypertrophic scarring/keloid.
Patients with hypersensitivity to aspirin.
Patients with oral isotretinoin intake in the past 6 months.
Pregnant and lactating women.
Treatment protocol and methodology
Pre_treatment assessment-Patients selected were informed of the nature of the study and written consent was obtained from the patients. The Demographic data such as age and sex of the selected patients, and duration of the disease were taken. Other history, like family history of acne, use of cosmetics, treatment history like topical and oral treatment for acne, topical steroids and other precipitating factors such as home remedies (mud, curd, honey etc.) were noted.
Patients were categorized according to Fitzpatrick index.
Methods
Patient reported to the Department of Periodontology and Oral Implantology, I.T.S. Center for Dental Studies and Research, Muradnagar.
A total of 200 patients of both the sex with different types of pigmentation were selected according to Fitzpatrick scale ranging from I-VI and enrolled for the study.
Thereafter study procedure was explained and written consent was taken from the patient and then they were seated on the dental chair.
Preoperative pictures were taken after patient drapes and head cap were placed at the camera setting of 2x, without flash light (chair position 90 degrees, without dental chair light).
Procedure
Healthy adult patients with pigmentation on their face were encouraged to participate in the study. As the study is split-face, on one side of face 30% Salicylic acid peel was used and on the other side 25% Glycolic acid peel was used.
Before starting the peel, the face was thoroughly cleansed with alcohol and/or acetone to remove oils from the skin followed by marking on the face with a marking pencil diving the face into two equal halves for the split face study. On the right side of the face Glycolic acid was applied and on the left side Salicylic acid was applied. Peels to be used are put separately in pellets and applied carefully on the face with help of the brush.
The peel was then left on for 3–5 minutes and patient were continously moniterd for any discomfort. Patient’s face was cleaned with water. A bland cleanser was used to remove any residual precipitate. After rinsing, a bland moisturizer was applied to the skin. Patient was given post-operative instructions and the procedure was repeated again after 2 weeks, twice followed by Platelet Rich Plasma (PRP) THERAPY. Changes in the face were recorded with indices every time the patient came.
Side effects if any, which appeared over the course of therapy were also recorded.
Postoperative instructions
For 24 to 48hrs patients was instructed
Not to wash with soap
Wash their skin with cool water rather than warm or hot water
Avoid exposure to direct heat or sun or dust
Keep skin lubricated and moisturized
Avoid products that dry the skin
Avoid exfoliators on your skin.
Use sunscreen with an SPF of at least 50
Not pick at blisters or scabs that form on your skin
Not smoke and avoid exposure to secondhand smoke
Avoid cosmetics
Patients were instructed to contact the doctor if they have any uncomfortable symptoms of any kind that don’t go away.
PRP therapy
Before the treatment, 8 ml of blood was collected from the patient into a special tube containing separation gel and anticoagulant Tube was then centrifuged for 8 min at 3500 rpm and PRP was obtained from the upper part of the buffy coat. A 32-G needle was used for superficial microinjections via mesotherapy technique, and injections are administered into the papillary dermis (1.2 – 2 mm deep) then the plasma was spread on your face, after which micro-needling across the forehead and cheeks was done to helps the face absorb proteins . Same post operative instruction were given.
Clinical parameters
Clinical photographs of the face were taken pre-operatively before peel, 15 days after peel,30 days after peel and 60 days after peel i.e after 30 from prp therapy. Fitzpatrick scale was measured
Result
Total of 200 patients were selected,out of which females outnumbered males in the ratio of 3:1.
Pictorial evaluation showed a good or very good response in (85)% in participants with salicylic acid peels in comparison to glycolic acid peels (70) which was significantly different.
|
|
Group |
Mean ±Std. Deviation |
Mean Difference ±S.E.M. |
P Value |
|
Baseline |
Salicylic acid |
3.100±1.9765 |
0.1800±0.7633 |
0.81NS |
|
Glycolic acid |
2.92±1.3855 |
|||
|
After 3 Months |
Salicylic acid |
.290±.1912 |
-0.4200±0.1706 |
0.024* |
|
Glycolic acid |
.710±.5043 |
|||
|
% Reduction |
Salicylic acid |
86.5896±12.01780 |
13.088±5.958 |
0.041* |
|
Glycolic acid |
73.5006±14.51216 |
Intergroup assessment showed that reduction of pigmentation with the salicylic acid peel 86.58% and Glycolic acid peel was 73.50% which is significant.
|
|
|
Difference Mean ±Std. Deviation |
P value |
|
Salicylic acid |
Baseline - After 3 Months |
2.8100±1.9958 |
.002** |
|
Glycolic acid |
Baseline - After 3 Months |
2.2100±1.1949 |
.001** |
In intragroup assessment the salicylic acid peel which has pre operative value of 3.10 which reduced post operatively to 0.29 showing significant difference while Glycolic acid peel has pre operative value of 2.92 which reduced post operatively to 0.71 showing significant difference.
Discussion
Melasma is a symmetric progressive hyperpigmentation of the facial skin that occurs in all races but has a predilection for darker skin phenotypes. Depigmenting agents, laser, and chemical peeling have been used alone and in combination for the treatment of melasma. [14] Melasma has been associated with hormonal imbalance, sun damage, and genetic predisposition. [15]
Clinicians and participants often use chemical peels as an adjunct to medical therapy because they produce complementary rapid therapeutic effects and improvements in skin appearance and texture. [16] Peels may allow topical agents to penetrate more efficiently into the skin and may improve post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation. [17] With good technique, peels are beneficial in dark-skinned participants. Chemical peeling has a low rate of complications and is popular due to the low costs involved and to a technique which is easy to learn. [18]
In a study conducted by Grimes, salicylic acid peel on acne showed an excellent to moderate response in 88% and mild clearance in 12% cases.
Glycolic acid, a member of AHA family is one of the most extensively used and versatile peeling agent, which has been found beneficial in a variety of skin condition including disorders of keratinization (xerosis, ichthyosis) as well as the commonly present skin problems like post inflammatory hyper-pigmentation, melasma, acne, dynamic rhytides, warts, actinic and seborrhoeic keratoses etc.[19] Skin rejuvenation is its most common indication. Burns et al[20] have documented the similar kind of results as obtained in our study in terms of improvement of post inflammatory hyperpigmentation with the use of glycolic acid peels. Wang et al[15] reported 90% improvement of overall acne lesions with glycolic acid and 69% reduction in hyperpigmentation and scarring. Grover C et al[21] reported good response in 78% patients with melasma.
Salicylic acid which is a beta hydroxy acid derivative and it eliminates intracellular lipids that are covalently bonded to the cornified epitheloid cells. 30% concentration is found to be most efficacious when indicated for multiple sessions, 3-5 times, every 3-4 weeks. Similar to our study, a parallel study conducted by Grimes et al[6] concluded that salicylic acid peel on acne and hyperpigmentation yeild excellent to moderate response in 88% and mild clearance in 12% cases. Another study by Fabbrocini et al.[22] illustrated that use of 33% salicylic acid application once for four months resulted in statistically significant reduction in melasma.
Similar to our study, Sarkar et al.[23] compared the efficacy ofglycolic acid (35%) and salicylic-mandelic (SM) acid (20% salicylic/10% mandelic acid) versus phytic combination peels in Indian patients with melasma. Chemical peeling was done after every 14 days in all groups until 12 weeks. MASI scoring after 12 weeks was 62.36% reduction in GA group, 60.98% reduction in SM group, and 44.71% in phytic acid group.
Age and sex distribution- In our study the maximum number of patients were between 30-50 years of age. With the observation most of them were females with 67% of them being mothers. At the end of the split face therapy, the side treated with salicylic acid showed better results than that treated with glycolic acid. In our study we observed moderate to excellent improvement in hyperpigmentation which were significantly better for salicylic acid than glycolic acid.
Limitation of the study is long term follow up is required is required to assess the efficacy of the chemical peel.
Conclusion
Salicylic acid is a safe and efficacious peeling agent for a number of dermatological and cosmetic problems, including acne vulgaris, melasma, photodamage, freckles, and lentigines. It can be safely used in dark skin types.
Conflict of Interest
None.
Source of Funding
None.
References
- AM Rossi, MI Perez. Treatment of hyperpigmentation.. Facial Plastic Surg Clin North Am 2011. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- Katsambas A, C Antoniou, Melasma. Melasma. Classification and treatment. J Euro Acad Dermatol Venery 1995. [Google Scholar]
- A Carolina, H Luciane, D Bartoli, M Hélio, A Miot. Melasma: A clinical and epidemiological review. An Bras Dermatol 2014. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- HH Ahn, IH Kim. Whitening effect of salicylic acid peels in Asian patients. Dermatol Surg 2006. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- PE Grimes. The safety and efficacy of salicylic acid chemical peels in darker racial-ethnic groups. Dermatol Surg 1999. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- M Landau. Chemical peels. Clin Dermatol 2008. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- WE Roberts. Chemical peeling in ethnic/dark skin. Dermatol Ther 2004. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- FF Becker, FP Langford, MG Rubin, P Speelman. A histological comparison of 50% and 70% glycolic acid peels using solutions with various pHs. Dermatol Surg 1996. [Google Scholar]
- CM Ditre. Glycolic acid peels. Dermatol Ther 2000. [Google Scholar]
- TC Fischer, E Perosino, F Poli, MS Viera, B Dreno. Cosmetic Dermatology European Expert Group Chemical peels in aesthetic dermatology: an update. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol 2009. [Google Scholar]
- P Bernal, M Perez, F Camacho. Management of Facial Hyperpigmentation. Am J Clin Dermatol 2000. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- G Fabbrocini, MP De Padova, A Tosti. Chemical peels: what’s new and what isn’t new but still works well. Facial Plast Surg 2009. [Google Scholar]
- JP Ortonne, T Passeron. Melanin pigmentary disorders: Treatment update. Dermatol Clin 2005. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- PE Grimes. Melasma. Etiologic and therapeutic considerations. Arch Dermatol 1995. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- L Atzori, MA Brundu, A Orru, P Biggio. Glycolic acid peeling in the treatment of acne. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol 1999. [Google Scholar]
- M Landau. Chemical peels. Clin Dermatol 2008. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- GD Monheit, MA Chastain. Chemical peels. Facial Plast Surg Clin North Am 2001. [Google Scholar]
- Z Erbgaci, C Akcali. Biweekly serial glycolic acid peels vs long term daily use of topical low strength glycolic acid in the treatment of atrophic acne scars. lnt J Dermatol 2000. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- RL Burns, PL Prevost- Blank, MA Lawry. Glycolic acid for postinflammatory hyperpigmentation in black patients. Dermotol Surg 1997. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- C Grover, BS Reddu. The therapeutic value of glycolic acid peels in dermatology. IJDVL 2003. [Google Scholar]
- G Fabbrocini, V De Vita, C Marasca, F Palmisano, G Monfrecola, . Salicylic acid for the treatment of melasma: new acquisitions for monitoring the clinical improvement. Skin Res Technol 2013. [Google Scholar]
- R Sarkar, V Garg, S Bansal, S Sethi, C Gupta. Comparative Evaluation of Efficacy and Tolerability of Glycolic Acid, Salicylic Mandelic Acid, and Phytic Acid Combination Peels in Melasma. Dermatol Surg 2016. [Google Scholar]